ARCHIVED CONTENT: In December 2020, the CZO program was succeeded by the Critical Zone Collaborative Network (CZ Net) ×

Wymore et al., 2019


Hysteretic response of solutes and turbidity at the event scale across forested tropical montane watersheds

Wymore, A., Leon M.C., Shanley J.B. McDowell W.H. (2019)
Frontiers in Earth Science Biogeoscience  


Concentration-discharge relationships are a key tool for understanding the sources and transport of material from watersheds to fluvial networks. Storm events in particular provide insight into variability in the sources of solutes and sediment within watersheds, and the hydrologic pathways that connect hillslope to stream channel. Here we examine high-frequency sensor-based specific conductance and turbidity data from multiple storm events across two watersheds (Quebrada Sonadora and Rio Icacos) with different lithology in the Luquillo Mountains of Puerto Rico, a forested tropical ecosystem. Our analyses include Hurricane Maria, a category 5 hurricane. To analyze hysteresis, we used a recently developed set of metrics to describe and quantify storm events including the hysteresis index (HI), which describes the directionality of hysteresis loops, and the flushing index (FI), which can be used to infer whether the mobilization of material is source or transport limited. We also examine the role of antecedent discharge to predict hysteretic behavior during storms. Overall, specific conductance and turbidity showed contrasting responses to storms. The hysteretic behavior of specific conductance was similar across sites, displaying clockwise hysteresis and a negative flushing index indicating proximal sources of solutes and consistent source limitation. In contrast, the directionality of turbidity hysteresis was significantly different between watersheds, although both had strong flushing behavior indicative of transport limitation. Overall, models that included antecedent discharge did not perform any better than models with peak discharge alone, suggesting that the magnitude and trajectory of an individual event was the strongest driver of material flux and hysteretic behavior. Hurricane Maria produced unique hysteresis metrics within both watersheds, indicating a distinctive response to this major hydrological event. The similarity in response of specific conductance to storms suggests that solute sources and pathways are similar in the two watersheds. The divergence in behavior for turbidity suggests that sources and pathways of particulate matter vary between the two watersheds. The use of high-frequency sensor data allows the quantification of storm events while index-based metrics of hysteresis allow for the direct comparison of complex storm events across a heterogeneous landscape and variable flow conditions.


Wymore, A., Leon M.C., Shanley J.B. McDowell W.H. (2019): Hysteretic response of solutes and turbidity at the event scale across forested tropical montane watersheds. Frontiers in Earth Science Biogeoscience. DOI: 10.3389/feart.2019.00126

This Paper/Book acknowledges NSF CZO grant support.

Associated Data

Icacos and Quebrada Sonadora - Streamflow / Discharge, Stream Suspended Sediment, Electrical Conductivity - Hysteresis Analysis (2016-2017)
2 components    Rio Icacos, Quebrada Sonadora    Water Chemistry, Hydrology    Wymore, Adam S.; Leon,Miguel C.; Shanley, James B.; McDowell, William H